Why Do Protective Tariffs Lead to Reduced International Trade

Author

Reads 614

Free stock photo of commerce, customs, duty
Credit: pexels.com, Free stock photo of commerce, customs, duty

Protective tariffs are a type of trade barrier that can have a significant impact on international trade. By increasing the cost of imported goods, they can make them less competitive in the domestic market.

This can lead to a decrease in imports, as consumers and businesses turn to domestic alternatives. For example, if a country imposes a tariff on imported steel, domestic steel producers may see an increase in sales.

As a result, the country's imports of steel may decrease. This can have a ripple effect throughout the economy, as other industries that rely on steel may also be affected.

The imposition of protective tariffs can also lead to retaliatory measures from other countries, further limiting trade.

What are Protective Tariffs?

Protective tariffs are a type of trade barrier that raises the cost of imported goods, making them less competitive in the domestic market. This is done by imposing a tax on imported goods, which increases their price and makes them less attractive to consumers.

A detailed collage of Euro and Dollar banknotes showcasing international currency exchange.
Credit: pexels.com, A detailed collage of Euro and Dollar banknotes showcasing international currency exchange.

The goal of protective tariffs is to protect domestic industries by giving them a competitive advantage over foreign producers. For example, if a domestic industry is struggling to compete with cheaper imports, a protective tariff can be imposed to level the playing field.

By increasing the cost of imports, protective tariffs can lead to reduced international trade, as consumers turn to domestic products instead. This can have a negative impact on the economy, particularly for countries that rely heavily on international trade.

Definition

Protective tariffs are a type of trade barrier that aims to shield domestic industries from foreign competition.

They work by imposing a tax on imported goods, making them more expensive for consumers and giving domestic producers a competitive advantage.

This tax is typically set at a rate that is high enough to deter imports, but not so high that it harms domestic industries.

The goal of protective tariffs is to protect domestic jobs and industries, but they can also lead to higher prices for consumers and reduced economic efficiency.

Scrabble tiles spelling 'China' and 'Tariffs' symbolize global trade issues.
Credit: pexels.com, Scrabble tiles spelling 'China' and 'Tariffs' symbolize global trade issues.

In reality, protective tariffs often benefit a select group of domestic producers at the expense of consumers and other industries.

By shielding domestic industries from foreign competition, protective tariffs can limit innovation and reduce the variety of goods available to consumers.

This can have long-term negative consequences for the economy, including reduced economic growth and increased inequality.

Tariffs

Tariffs are a key component of protective tariffs, and they work by imposing taxes on imported goods to protect domestic producers. This can lead to a reduction in imports.

The government imposes tariffs to shield domestic producers, which can result in a decrease in the number of imports coming into the country.

History of Protectionist Policies

Protectionist policies have a long and complex history, with many countries implementing such policies to gain an advantage over their trading partners.

Adam Smith's views on free trade have been disputed, with Friedrich List arguing that Smith's advocacy for free trade was disingenuous, aiming to benefit British industry at the expense of underdeveloped foreign competition.

Colorful stacked shipping containers against a vibrant blue sky, conveying global trade and logistics.
Credit: pexels.com, Colorful stacked shipping containers against a vibrant blue sky, conveying global trade and logistics.

Economic historians have found that historically, free trade is the exception and protectionism the rule.

Protectionism has often been used as a shock absorber in response to sudden shifts in comparative advantage, such as the opening up of New World frontiers in the late 19th century, which led to higher agricultural tariffs in Europe.

Speech of Henry Clay on Industry

In the early 19th century, Henry Clay, a prominent American statesman, advocated for a strong industrial base. He believed that the government should play an active role in promoting industry through protectionist policies.

The protective tariff was a key part of Clay's plan to boost domestic industry. By imposing tariffs, the government reduced the number of imports, giving domestic producers a competitive edge.

As a result of Clay's efforts, the government imposed tariffs to protect domestic producers, which in turn reduced the number of imports. The other nations responded by imposing tariffs of their own, reducing the export of the nation that levied tariffs.

The outcome of Clay's policy was a reduction in both imports and exports for the nation. This was a direct result of the retaliatory tariffs imposed by other nations in response to the initial tariffs.

Historical Context

Creative world map made from assorted coins on a solid gray backdrop, symbolizing global finance.
Credit: pexels.com, Creative world map made from assorted coins on a solid gray backdrop, symbolizing global finance.

Protectionist policies have been a part of human history for thousands of years, with ancient civilizations like Greece and Rome imposing tariffs to protect their domestic industries.

The first recorded protectionist policy was in ancient Greece around 500 BCE, where the Athenians imposed a 10% tariff on imported goods.

In the 16th century, the English government began to actively promote domestic industries through subsidies and tariffs, a policy that was later adopted by other European nations.

The British Navigation Acts of 1651 were a key example of this, requiring colonies to use British ships and ports for trade, effectively giving British merchants a monopoly on the transatlantic trade.

The American Revolution was in part sparked by the British government's refusal to repeal these acts, which restricted American trade and commerce.

The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 was a major milestone in the history of protectionist policies, imposing high tariffs on imported goods and leading to retaliatory measures from other countries, which exacerbated the Great Depression.

Impact on International Trade

Man in Blue Coverall Inspecting A White Car
Credit: pexels.com, Man in Blue Coverall Inspecting A White Car

Protective tariffs can lead to a significant decrease in international trade, making it harder for countries to import and export goods.

The imposition of tariffs on imported goods can cause a substantial increase in the cost of production for domestic industries, leading to higher prices for consumers.

According to our previous discussion, tariffs on imported steel have been shown to increase the cost of production for domestic steel manufacturers by up to 30%.

Higher production costs can lead to a decrease in competitiveness for domestic industries, causing them to lose market share to foreign competitors.

As we've seen in the case of the automotive industry, tariffs on imported auto parts can lead to a decrease in the number of foreign vehicles sold in the domestic market.

Reduced international trade can also lead to a decrease in economic growth, as countries rely heavily on trade to stimulate their economies.

Tariffs can also lead to retaliatory measures from other countries, further reducing international trade and causing a ripple effect throughout the global economy.

The effects of reduced international trade can be seen in the decline of international trade agreements, such as the Trans-Pacific Partnership, which was abandoned due to the imposition of tariffs.

Country-Specific Examples

Container ship at Hamburg port during sunset, illustrating global commerce and freight transport.
Credit: pexels.com, Container ship at Hamburg port during sunset, illustrating global commerce and freight transport.

Argentina's experience with protectionism is a stark reminder of the drawbacks of tariffs. In the 1940s, Juan Perón implemented a system of almost complete protectionism against imports, cutting off Argentina from the international market.

This led to a domestically oriented industry with high production costs, unable to compete in international markets. Beef and grain production, Argentina's main export goods, stagnated due to the protectionist policies.

Argentina's GDP per capita fell to less than half of the United States' by 1954, from 80% equivalent before the 1930s.

Examples

In Japan, the concept of "ikigai" refers to finding purpose and fulfillment in life, which is closely tied to the country's unique cultural values and customs.

The Japanese concept of "honne" and "tatemae" highlights the importance of social harmony and respect for tradition.

In Sweden, the idea of "lagom" emphasizes the importance of finding balance and moderation in life.

Sweden's strong social safety net and emphasis on work-life balance contribute to its high standard of living.

Container ships docked at Hamburg Container Terminal under clear skies, showcasing global trade.
Credit: pexels.com, Container ships docked at Hamburg Container Terminal under clear skies, showcasing global trade.

In India, the concept of "dharma" emphasizes the importance of living a life of duty and morality.

The Indian caste system, which is a complex and nuanced social hierarchy, is rooted in the concept of "varna".

In Brazil, the concept of "jeitinho brasileiro" refers to the country's unique cultural approach to getting things done, which emphasizes creativity and resourcefulness.

Brazil's diverse cultural heritage, shaped by its African, European, and indigenous influences, is reflected in its vibrant music and art scene.

China

China's economic policies have been a topic of debate. China pursues a mercantilist and predatory policy, keeping its currency undervalued to accumulate trade surpluses.

This policy, as described by Paul Krugman in 2010, involves selling renminbi and buying foreign currency to keep the renminbi low, giving the Chinese manufacturing sector a cost advantage over its competitors. China's surpluses drain US demand and slow economic recovery in other countries with which China trades.

The Chinese government's actions are equivalent to imposing high tariffs or providing export subsidies, according to Krugman. This has a significant impact on the global economy.

However, the international community, through the IMF, rejected the notion that the renminbi was undervalued in 2015.

Argentina

Explore global commerce with a cargo ship and towering cranes at Hamburg Port under a clear sky.
Credit: pexels.com, Explore global commerce with a cargo ship and towering cranes at Hamburg Port under a clear sky.

Argentina had a remarkable economic performance from the 1860s to 1930, becoming a "super-exporter" with a diverse basket of products exported to European and American countries.

The country's economy boomed due to low trade costs, trade liberalization, and a multilateral and open economic system.

From the 1940s, Argentina's economic strategy shifted to protectionism, largely cutting off the country from the international market.

This protectionist approach led to a domestically oriented industry with high production costs, unable to compete internationally.

Output of beef and grain, Argentina's main export goods, stagnated, and the IAPI shortchanged growers, stifling agricultural production and exports.

Despite these shortcomings, protectionism allowed for an exponential growth of the internal market, with radio sales increasing 600% and fridge sales growing 218%.

Argentina's economy continued to grow, but at a slower pace than the world as a whole or its neighbors, Brazil and Chile.

By 1954, Argentina's GDP per capita had fallen to less than half of that of the United States, from being 80% equivalent before the 1930s.

United States

Shipping containers and cranes at Hamburg port showcasing global trade.
Credit: pexels.com, Shipping containers and cranes at Hamburg port showcasing global trade.

The United States is a country with a strong focus on innovation, as seen in its thriving tech industry.

The country has a diverse economy, with major industries including finance, healthcare, and manufacturing.

From Silicon Valley to Wall Street, the US is home to many of the world's top companies.

In terms of education, the US has a well-developed system with top-ranked universities like Harvard and Stanford.

However, the country also struggles with issues of income inequality and access to affordable healthcare.

Barriers to Trade

Non-tariff barriers are used by nations to bolster their economies and protect domestic interests. They can include laws or regulations that protect domestic industries against foreign competition.

Subsidies for domestic goods are one type of non-tariff barrier that can give domestic industries an unfair advantage. Import quotas and regulations on import quality are also used to limit foreign competition.

These barriers can be particularly challenging for small businesses, which may not have the resources to navigate complex regulations.

Jessie Smith

Senior Writer

Jessie Smith is a versatile writer with a passion for crafting informative and engaging content. With a keen interest in travel and aviation, Jessie has established herself as a go-to expert on air travel procedures, providing readers with valuable insights and practical advice. Her articles are a testament to her dedication to helping others navigate the complexities of air travel, making her a trusted voice in the industry.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.