Utopia of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas: Which Cruise Ship Reigns Supreme

Imagine setting sail on a luxurious cruise, surrounded by breathtaking ocean views and endless entertainment options. Utopia of the Seas and Icon of the Seas are two of the most impressive ships in the industry, each offering a unique experience.

Utopia of the Seas boasts an impressive 18 decks, providing ample space for passengers to explore. Icon of the Seas, on the other hand, features a more intimate 18-deck layout.

Both ships offer a wide range of dining options, but Utopia of the Seas takes it to the next level with its exclusive robot bartenders. Icon of the Seas, however, shines with its impressive 40-foot-tall rock climbing wall.

For another approach, see: Allure of the Seas vs Utopia of the Seas

Icon of the Seas has a massive main waterpark called Category 6, featuring six slides, including the tallest drop slide at sea.

The ship's waterpark is a go-to destination for waterslide enthusiasts, with a separate water park dedicated to kids as part of the Surfside neighborhood.

Utopia of the Seas has three slides, but its secret weapon is the Ultimate Abyss, the world's longest dry slide at sea, spanning 259 feet from start to finish.

You can experience the Ultimate Abyss, which takes you from the 16th deck to the sixth deck in just 19 seconds, with the help of rollers that maintain your speed.

Icon of the Seas has an extensive selection of seven pools with unique vibes, while Utopia of the Seas has five pools, but no infinity pool like the one in The Hideaway adults-only neighborhood of Icon.

The Utopia of the Seas and the Icon of the Seas may seem similar at first glance, but they have some key differences that are worth noting.

The Utopia of the Seas is set to debut on July 22, 2024, while the Icon of the Seas will start sailing on January 27, 2024.

The Icon of the Seas is significantly larger than the Utopia of the Seas, with a gross tonnage of 250,800 compared to the Utopia's 236,860.

In terms of passenger capacity, the Icon of the Seas can accommodate 7,514 guests, while the Utopia of the Seas can accommodate 5,666.

Here's a comparison of the two ships in a table:

The Icon of the Seas has a longer sailing itinerary, with 7-night cruises, while the Utopia of the Seas offers 3-4 night cruises.

When it comes to accommodations, Icon of the Seas stands out for its spacious and luxurious suites, including the 2,100-square-foot Icon Suite. The Icon Suite features a private balcony, living area, and dining room.

Icon of the Seas offers a variety of accommodation categories, including the AquaClass and Icon Suites. These suites offer perks like private balconies and access to the exclusive Solarium pool.

The Icon of the Seas has a total of 7 neighborhoods, each with its own unique character and accommodation options. The ship's neighborhood layout allows for a more intimate and personalized experience.

Worth a look: Private Mailbox vs Po Box

Icon of the Seas' accommodations are designed to provide a seamless transition between indoor and outdoor spaces, with many rooms featuring floor-to-ceiling windows and sliding glass doors. This design element allows guests to take in the ocean views from the comfort of their own rooms.

Icon of the Seas has a total of 2,337 staterooms, offering a range of options for guests. From cozy interior rooms to spacious suites with ocean views, there's something for every taste and budget.

In contrast, Utopia of the Seas has a more limited range of accommodation options, with 1,756 staterooms available. While this still offers a decent selection, it's significantly fewer than Icon of the Seas.

Dining on Utopia of the Seas and Icon of the Seas is a treat, with a variety of options to satisfy any craving. Both ships share some dining venues, including the Main Dining Room, Sorrento's, Chops Grille, Hooked Seafood, and Windjammer buffet.

You can also find Izumi, a specialty restaurant serving Japanese cuisine, on both ships. Giovanni's Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar is a unique spot on Utopia of the Seas, featuring a two-story layout and a terrace overlooking The Boardwalk neighborhood. Icon of the Seas has a one-story Giovanni's Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar located in the Royal Promenade.

Icon of the Seas has some exclusive dining venues, such as AquaDome Market, a food hall with five different stalls offering various cuisines, and Basecamp, a spot near Thrill Island serving drinks and treats like pretzel bites and crispy shrimp bao buns. Utopia of the Seas has a new two-story Giovanni’s Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar with a terrace that overlooks The Boardwalk neighborhood.

Here's a list of restaurants and casual dining spots you can find on both Icon of the Seas and Utopia of the Seas:

Both ships also have bars like the Schooner Bar, Playmakers Sports Bar, and Boleros. Icon of the Seas has some unique bars, such as 1400 Lobby Bar, Bubbles, Dueling Pianos, Hideaway Bar, Lou’s Jazz ‘n Blues, Rye & Bean, Swim & Tonic, The Lemon Post, and The Overlook. Utopia of the Seas has a bar called Pesky Parrot, a tiki bar serving fruity cocktails in a tropical setting.

Icon of the Seas has an indoor AquaTheater with a show called Aqua Action!, while Utopia of the Seas has an outdoor AquaTheater with a show called Aqua80Too. Both ships have an ice skating rink with different names, and various shows held in the Royal Theater on most nights of the cruise.

When comparing the costs of Utopia and Icon of the Seas, one of the most significant differences is the price of cruises. Cruises aboard Icon of the Seas start at roughly $3,000 for two adults in an interior stateroom.

Utopia, on the other hand, offers sailings that start at roughly $1,200 for two adults in an interior room.

The Utopia of the Seas and the Icon of the Seas both feature eight distinct neighborhoods, designed to provide unique experiences for different types of travelers. These neighborhoods are a game-changer for navigating the massive size of these cruise ships.

Both ships have a Royal Promenade, which is the main hub for shopping, dining, and entertainment. But the Icon of the Seas takes it to the next level with floor-to-ceiling ocean views.

The Utopia of the Seas has the same neighborhoods as the Wonder of the Seas, while the Icon of the Seas has new neighborhoods like Surfside, AquaDome, Chill Island, Thrill Island, and The Hideaway.

You'll have a wealth of accommodation choices on both the Utopia of the Seas and the Icon of the Seas.

The cheapest option is an inside cabin, while the most luxurious option is an incredible multi-storey suite that costs upwards of £20,000 per person per week.

Utopia of the Seas has more guest staterooms than Icon of the Seas, but Icon has a higher maximum capacity, hosting around 600 more guests.

Icon of the Seas features the Ultimate Family Townhouse, a three-level suite with family-centric amenities like an in-suite slide and private cinema.

Utopia of the Seas offers a dedicated suite area with private amenities, including access to the Suite Lounge and Coastal Kitchen restaurant.

Icon of the Seas has a private restaurant within the Suite Neighborhood called The Grove, which is exclusive to suite guests.

The Icon of the Seas has eight official neighborhoods, each offering unique experiences for different types of travelers.

One of the neighborhoods, Suite Neighborhood, is an exclusive area for suite guests, providing private dining, a sun deck, and luxury amenities.

The Icon of the Seas features neighborhoods like AquaDome, Thrill Island, Chill Island, and Surfside, which are not found on other Royal Caribbean ships.

These new neighborhoods on the Icon of the Seas offer exciting experiences like the AquaTheater, waterparks, and mini-golf.

The Utopia of the Seas, on the other hand, features the standard seven neighborhoods found on Royal Caribbean's Oasis-class ships, plus the Suite Neighborhood.

The Oasis Class ships, which include the Utopia of the Seas, were the first to introduce the concept of neighborhoods, themed districts with certain features grouped together.

All Oasis Class ships, except the Icon of the Seas, have seven neighborhoods because they do not have the Suite Neighborhood.

Both Icon of the Seas and Utopia of the Seas are split into eight distinct neighborhoods, making them easier to navigate for passengers.

On a similar theme: Norwegian Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean

Both Utopia of the Seas and Icon of the Seas are incredible options, but they cater to different needs. Icon of the Seas is designed with families in mind, featuring more family accommodation options and improved dining for kids.

The two ships share many experiences, but Icon has more new features, as Utopia of the Seas offers many experiences seen before on Wonder of the Seas and other Oasis-class ships.

If you're looking for something unique, Icon's Surfside neighborhood and new restaurants might be worth considering.